Your engagement ring symbolizes your love story—but just like relationships grow and evolve, sometimes your ring should, too. Whether you're celebrating a milestone anniversary or simply want something that reflects your current style, upgrading your engagement ring can be a meaningful and exciting decision. Here’s how to know if it’s the right time—and how to do it right.
Why People Upgrade Their Engagement Rings
Upgrading doesn’t mean discarding sentiment. In fact, it often adds to the story.
Common reasons to upgrade:
-
Celebrating a milestone anniversary
-
Evolving personal style
-
Improved budget since the original purchase
-
Wanting a larger center stone or different shape
-
Switching from natural diamond to moissanite (or vice versa)
Popular Upgrade Options
1. Change the Center Stone
Swap your original center stone for a larger diamond or lab-grown moissanite—an ethical, affordable, and brilliant option.
Tip: Moissanite is an increasingly popular upgrade choice for couples looking for max sparkle at a better value.
2. Update the Setting
Changing the band or setting (e.g., from prong to bezel) can dramatically transform your ring without replacing the stone.
3. Add Side Stones or a Halo
Enhance your current stone by adding a halo of smaller diamonds or flanking it with side stones for more brilliance and dimension.
Things to Consider Before Upgrading
-
Sentimental value – Keep your original stone and reset it into a pendant or another piece.
-
Budget – Set a realistic range before exploring options.
-
Ring size – If upgrading the setting, recheck your ring size for comfort and fit.
-
Resale or trade-in – Some jewelers accept trade-ins toward your upgrade.
Not Sure Where to Start? We Can Help.
At Scott Bonomo Diamond Setting, we specialize in handmade, heirloom-quality rings using ethically sourced diamonds and moissanite. If you're thinking about an upgrade, we're happy to help you choose the right piece from our collection or guide you through redesign options.
Let Your Next Chapter Shine
Your love story is still being written—why not let your ring reflect the newest chapter? Browse our current ring styles or reach out with questions about redesigning or upgrading.